it seems i missed that this has a few flowers textures in it. did you make those/are they sourced from somewhere/what license are they under?
delphinium, lazarus, mannagrass and thistle
submitted for re review with no comment, no answer on the flower textures, and converts the cc by sa 1.0 assets to cc0, without any seeming link to where permission was gained for this change
The flower textures were submitted by the user Timbits a while ago under cc-by-sa 3, it was never in documentation though but I still had the bitmap he supplied with license under wip.
Timbits is a player on Xanadu server who graciously made some flower textures for the baked clay mod and sent me a texture sheet. What else do I need ?
Yes, thanks for clarifying the source of the flower textures in this mod, they are fine.
The remaining issue is the glazed terracotta textures which are licensed under the CCPL, also known as CC-BY-SA 1.0. @rubenwardy was going to add this license to ContentDB so the package can be properly licensed under it, but you have changed the license in the file to CC-0 now. Did you ask the original author for a relicensing or was this an accident?
it looks like the license file is fine. because cc by sa 1.0 is not upgradable (and this has cc by sa 3.0, cc0 media), i think this is one of the rare edge cases we can approve using free/other permanently for media (normally it is only used as a placeholder for licenses not added to cdb in review)
looking at the license you say creative commons, https://notabug.org/TenPlus1/bakedclay/src/master/license.txt#L24, but dont actually have a media license here. looking at the license text on the linked website, its the ccpl license. further digging reveals that that is just the dumb orginal name for the cc by sa 1.0 license https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/1.0/legalcode. looking at https://creativecommons.org/share-your-work/licensing-considerations/compatible-licenses we can see that cc by sa 2.0 is the first license where we can upgrade to a newer version, so cant upgrade it. (as cdb lowest option is cc by sa 3.0). looking at cc by sa 1.0, it is spdx listed https://spdx.org/licenses/CC-BY-SA-1.0.html which means cdb should be fine to include it as a license option, just @rubenwardy needs to add it to cdb, then you can switch your media license to that, and then should be all good
it seems i missed that this has a few flowers textures in it. did you make those/are they sourced from somewhere/what license are they under?
delphinium, lazarus, mannagrass and thistle
submitted for re review with no comment, no answer on the flower textures, and converts the cc by sa 1.0 assets to cc0, without any seeming link to where permission was gained for this change
The flower textures were submitted by the user Timbits a while ago under cc-by-sa 3, it was never in documentation though but I still had the bitmap he supplied with license under wip.
still has not been addressed
Timbits is a player on Xanadu server who graciously made some flower textures for the baked clay mod and sent me a texture sheet. What else do I need ?
Yes, thanks for clarifying the source of the flower textures in this mod, they are fine.
The remaining issue is the glazed terracotta textures which are licensed under the CCPL, also known as CC-BY-SA 1.0. @rubenwardy was going to add this license to ContentDB so the package can be properly licensed under it, but you have changed the license in the file to CC-0 now. Did you ask the original author for a relicensing or was this an accident?
Oops, that was a mistake on my part, I assumed "Creative Commons" was CC0, changed it back.
it looks like the license file is fine. because cc by sa 1.0 is not upgradable (and this has cc by sa 3.0, cc0 media), i think this is one of the rare edge cases we can approve using free/other permanently for media (normally it is only used as a placeholder for licenses not added to cdb in review)